There are numerous hopes amongst comedian e book followers (I am certainly one of them) which can be using on Todd Philips’s Joker origin film, starring Joaquin Phoenix within the titular position because the Clown Prince of Crime. Two primary hopes are to provide us a Joker that lastly lives as much as the legendary efficiency of Heath Ledger because the Joker in The Darkish Knight.
The opposite hope is to lastly have a comic-book film win the very best image Oscar and supply the last word stamp of approval on comedian e book films as severe fare worthy of the best vital acclaim and acknowledgment. Sadly, in taking pictures for these two lofty targets, the precise film itself turns away so fully from its comedian e book roots that it would as properly not be a Joker film in any respect, only a story of a mentally ailing man who occurs to put on clown make-up.
For starters, let me simply say that any comparability between Heath Ledger and Joaquin Phoenix are rendered null by the truth that the characters they painting, other than sharing the identical identify, are so wildly completely different that they could as properly be two separate folks. Ledger’s Joker was a felony mastermind who hid his nihilistic outlook beneath the guise of madness. The world noticed the Joker as a madman, however he was in each means an evil genius able to pushing the world’s biggest detective to his psychological limits.
Associated: Joaquin Phoenix Is Not Completely Against Doing Joker 2
This concept of the Joker as a mastermind has stayed constant throughout each comedian, cartoon and film adaptation. Till Phoenix got here alongside. His Joker is an exceedingly bizarre man, pushed by his violent impulses and being swept up within the tide of occasions. His first homicide is a defensive act in opposition to three bullies. His subsequent few crimes are intensely private, spur-of-the-moment acts which can be the actions of a sufferer lastly appearing out in opposition to his oppressors, reasonably than these of a villain reveling in his evil nature. Even after he begins a revolution on the streets, it’s made clear that was by no means his intention, nor have been the occasions ever in his management after he by accident lit the fuse on the powder keg that’s Gotham’s decrease, disenfranchised courses.
So the character we lastly get is extra within the vein of the unnamed narrator from Battle Membership than the grasp of chaotic evil that’s the comedian e book Joker. We will think about the Jokers performed by Ledger, Hamill, Nicholson, and even Leto giving Batman a tough time. Phoenix’s Joker, however, would barely final a second in such a state of affairs. He isn’t a supervillain or perhaps a villain. In a single scene, we see him kill a person who had wronged him and spare one other who had been his pal. That was not the motion of the comedian e book Joker, however merely a deranged however kind-hearted man who was appearing out in opposition to a selected particular person he felt had wronged him.
Todd Philips has repeatedly insisted that there’s not going to be a Joker meets Batman sequel for his film, and that fully is smart. This Joker is under no circumstances suited to develop into Batman’s arch-enemy. And that’s the reason, from the attitude of a comic book e book fan, this film in the end dissatisfied me, regardless of Phoenix’s masterful efficiency. I got here to the theater hoping to see the origin of comicdom’s most diabolical villain, the madman who’s famend for finishing up essentially the most sadistic acts of torture and mayhem with unsuppressed glee, the unstoppable drive of nature pitted in opposition to the immovable Batman, the charismatic cult chief who guidelines the Gotham underworld and virtually hypnotizes his military of lackeys into doing his bidding.
As an alternative, I noticed a film a few unhappy, lonely man struggling to take care of his psychological sickness whereas beset by poverty and an uncaring society, till he lastly snaps and goes on a vengeful rampage, by accident beginning a revolution and changing into a people hero of kinds within the course of. One thing like The Killing Joke, however sadder and bleaker. Whereas in The Killing Joke, the easy, kind-hearted man is was a madman by falling right into a poisonous vat of chemical compounds that warp his thoughts, right here Arthur Fleck AKA Joker stays the identical, unhappy, lonely man, solely with a extra violent streak.
It was a superb, pleasurable film inside its parameters, however I am nonetheless ready to observe a Joker origin film that does justice to the character I grew up studying about. Till then I can all the time rewatch Breaking Dangerous, whose lead character follows a extra satisfying trajectory of reworking from a easy, common man right into a scheming, diabolical and in the end unrepentant crime lord.
The views and opinions expressed on this article are these of the creator and don’t essentially mirror the official coverage or place of Movieweb.
Author with a eager curiosity in expertise and popular culture.